huge gators

[Locke]

Originally Posted by OutlawZ

you are slaying huge gators but not getting the water?

did this quest specify where the gators had to be found?
for some reason that popped into my head...

other than that, not sure why.
go to a different location and try some more.

Yea, location may be why you are not getting anything.

Try going to the cave in Cutthroat Island because that is near Padres Del Fuego where the quest originally resides.