What "NEW"(redone) island is your favorite?

[MacIronhawk]

Which redone island is your favorite, Port Royal, Tortuga, or Padres Del Fuego? Please post why.

[The Skirata Clan]

Tortuga... hands down.

[akamystic]

I honestly have not had enough time getting lost on any of them to vote just yet. I think they all have unique features......I'll post again after I've had more time to explore.

[jason davy]

Port Royal. It's really the only "new" island that I actually like the layout of.

[Erich Uchiha]

Port Royal definitly, It added new things to the island without getting rid of the mere feel of the island. If you smell what im cookin'

[Cannonfury]

Originally Posted by indypirate

Port Royal definitly, It added new things to the island without getting rid of the mere feel of the island. If you smell what im cookin'

I say port royal and thats the bottom line cause Maria Cannonfury said so

[AdmiralSavvy]

Port Royal cause, like Erich said, the island still has that PR feeling to it, but with some improvements, not bad....

[Machazzard]

I thoroughly enjoy the new PDF!!! It is alittle darker and more erie! I love it, perfect for a pirate game!

[The Skirata Clan]

Is it me or New PDF has earthquakes?

[jason davy]

Originally Posted by The Skirata Clan

Is it me or New PDF has earthquakes?

I had up a browser today with a POTCO window in the background, and it seemed to be shaking badly. I thought somebody might be bumping me while I was AFK, so I checked it out, and it did indeed appear to be an "earthquake." O_o

I mean, it's a volcano, so I guess it would kinda make sense.

[Kat Five Knives]

I haven't seen the volcano erupt. Did they take that out??? I thought it was really cool..

[Jack Sharkbane]

Eh, I'd say port royal and pdf are tied, port royal for the way the did fort charles, I thought that was nice. but pdf had a little erieness to it, but its in danger of winning my vote for its difficulty of exploration.

[Captain Del]

Port Royal. Something about its whole layout in general makes the island feel quite realistic, as it really fits the "Caribbean-ish" and "piratey" moods.

[combatlizzy]

Port Royal definitely has the best qualities IMHO...seems to have everything and is laid out in a grand manner.

PDF does have Earthquakes and is a bit spooky...not that it is a bad thing. But, I feel the need to check over me shoulder there, every now and then...

Tortuga is, well Tortuga...seems like alot of running around to get things done there.

[Rackat]

currentl, i would have to go with port royal. i like the new pdf, but the old one was fine. now, if they redo cuba and add some new shops and npc's, that will probably take the lead..for me.