Mafia Suggestions

[alana stormbreaker]

I'm not sure if anyone is interested in playing another mafia game, but if we do (I'd be in, for sure!) I have a couple of suggestions, and I'm sure others do as well.

The main thing that I noticed was different in playing on a forum versus playing with a group of people IRL is that when accusations are made the accused had a chance to reply back before the final vote.

I'm sure it was intended to work that way in the forum game, but it never quite worked out that way for whatever reason.

So my suggestion is to add another phase- a 'trial' or accusation phase. It would last just as long as a night/day phase and would allow whoever had the top votes in the voting off thread to plea their case and change people's minds before a final verdict is decided.

I just think there's wasn't really enough time to really get a chance for everyone's character to come out. Adding another phase allows for even MORE backstabbin' and lyin'!!

What does everyone else think? I'm sure there are other ideas to make this game great, I would love it if it became a regular, monthly game- two-three weeks worth of game with another week/week and a half for people to sign up for the next game.

[Garfieldo]

Originally Posted by alana stormbreaker

I'm not sure if anyone is interested in playing another mafia game, but if we do (I'd be in, for sure!) I have a couple of suggestions, and I'm sure others do as well.

The main thing that I noticed was different in playing on a forum versus playing with a group of people IRL is that when accusations are made the accused had a chance to reply back before the final vote.

I'm sure it was intended to work that way in the forum game, but it never quite worked out that way for whatever reason.

So my suggestion is to add another phase- a 'trial' or accusation phase. It would last just as long as a night/day phase and would allow whoever had the top votes in the voting off thread to plea their case and change people's minds before a final verdict is decided.

I just think there's wasn't really enough time to really get a chance for everyone's character to come out. Adding another phase allows for even MORE backstabbin' and lyin'!!

What does everyone else think? I'm sure there are other ideas to make this game great, I would love it if it became a regular, monthly game- two-three weeks worth of game with another week/week and a half for people to sign up for the next game.

You know, I like that idea lot. We ended the game kind of early anyway, so another phase wouldn't hurt. Thank you for the suggestion.

Oh, and good job as Gunner.

[alana stormbreaker]

Originally Posted by Garfieldo

Oh, and good job as Gunner.

Haha, thanks! I never realized how hard it would actually be to use bad grammar/spelling!

[Fillyteen]

I would like another go at this game, it was fun

[davy redflint]

aye sorry i was marooned by the hurricane and miss out, maybe more people will play next time. i had 2 of those navy #$$#@ figure out. lol

[Swash]

What happened is mafia over?

[icemage]

I can finally post. Ever since I was kicked out Mr.Lovelocket and i have been pying on the Navy and the Pirates. looks like the Navy were being spyed on too. Mwahaha

[Mr.LoveLocket]

Awesome game! yeah i love your ideas alana!

[alana stormbreaker]

yup, the navy got us pirates

[Mr.LoveLocket]

yep no mafia champion for us!

[davy redflint]

aye it was rigged lol we get em next time, where r sign (dead pirates) lol

[MacIronhawk]

Originally Posted by Garfieldo

You know, I like that idea lot. We ended the game kind of early anyway, so another phase wouldn't hurt. Thank you for the suggestion.

Oh, and good job as Gunner.

I would've liked to see myself die.
That would have been fun to see what happened to me as I was the last pirate.
You think next time taht could happen?

I just thought it would've been fun.

[Harukantos]

Seemed the game would be moe fun if it were on the live game, after all, it'd be easier to talk to people and investigate them as said to be possible.

[Jack Sharkbane]

i tried signing up, but it didn't work.any suggestions?

[Jack I]

Mafia isn't currently going on, mate. ^^

The games already been played already for this round, but judging by the reaction we got from it, it's possible that we will have another round planned for a future competition.