Which movie was better?

[Nick]

I liked the second one over the first one.

[Master Tricky Crumbleflip]

I liked the original better. It didn't seem to drag on as much, and the second movie had too many unimportant scenes showing monsters.

But I did like the jar of dirt. ^_^

[SpinMarty]

I thought the first was better because the characters were a fresh surprise. In the second you expected JS to act as he did, as well as the others. Don't get me wrong, I still enjoyed them both.

[TooHip]

The first movie will live in my mind as the better of the two, but I wonder how much of that is predicated on the fact that there was so much hype the second had to live up to. That, and the second clearly was a setup for the third.

In any case, I enjoyed both.

[timmyastro]

I loved the second movie!

[Tepcat]

I loved the second movie - great special effects without being too obvious about it and I loved the ending. My jaw dropped when it WASN'T Captain Jack Sparrow who appeared - Bring on number 3!

[Maleficent_Rocks]

Although the first will have a place in my heart forever, I'm personally voting the 2nd movie. I got to see that one at the El Capitan in Hollywood and Geoffrey Rush at the end. That was the BEST! People in the theatre were just shocked, you could hear a collective GASP.

[PinkTinkPixie]

Dead Man's Chest was definately a lot better. I remember not being too fond of the first one the year it came out, but as soon as I saw the sequal, I loved it

~Pink

[PaperClip]

I personally liked the first one better. I think it had a better story board, and like some others say, it didn't drag on and on and on.

[Volitan]

I liked the second one better, but I still loved the first one a lot too.

[FoolsLove]

Second one all the way. Though you can't help but love them both.

[soccergals]

I prefered the first; it was so much more fun to watch, and I had no idea what to expect with it.

[Qui-gon]

I like the first one better, it's a classic. But the second one is really, really good.

~Q/S

[Pinkdust]

In my opinion, the first movie was better by far. It was funnier and had a better plot... the second one dragged on a bit and... it seemed a bit more... un-piratey? That's it, I suppose... it's hard to describe.

[Garfieldo]

Originally Posted by LoveDefying

Second one all the way. Though you can't help but love them both.

Agreed, agreed. The first was great, but there's just something about the second that makes it so much better...