Can't complete Black Pearl quest

[jackhut]

I've been part of 2 groups that have captured the Black Pearl, but I have not been able to complete the quest. It shows up as 99% complete on my quest list. At the end of the quest the message says to visit Jack Sparrow for my reward, but I cannot find him. Isn't he supposed to be in the one of the taverns on Tortuga? Can anyone help me out of this?

PS - I have been a gunner both times. Does only the captain get to see Jack Sparrow or should the entire crew get to see him? It would seem to be pointless to do the quest if only the captain gets credit for it.