Voodoo staff V.S Voodoo doll. What is best.

[cody]

voodoo doll

[Lucas76020]

The staff is way better because you can use it at a range and when the enemy comes up you can just run away again, but you have to charge your casts and your spells might fizzle. But the thing i hate about the doll is that you have to attune people. You have to walk up and touch people with the doll before you can attack while enemies can attune you a planet away. Thats just not right

[Dr. Zeppers]

Most useful? The Doll
Most destructive? The Staff

I do not know which is "best" because that would depend on each pirate I would think.

[greatertater]

However I want to change my earlier choice because it has occurred to me the doll is the only way to heal yourself or someone else in the game. That alone makes it the most useful imo. I have to resist the temptation to use the doll so much thereby leveling it too quickly because I love this "weapon."

However the image of Blackbeard actually violently pillaging his way through the Caribbean with a dolly in his hand is quite comical. Were there enough fans of the game to reach the necessary commonality to achieve comedic affect this would make a pretty good satiracal sketch for someone so motivated.

[MacIronhawk]

For me there's no competition.
I think the doll is much better than the staff. It has more hexes and you can heal yourself. The staff's great but the doll is still my choice.

[Nack]

voooodoooo staaaff 4ever!!!!!!!!!

[jason davy]

Originally Posted by Tuefenhandel

It's all but impossible to get to level 30 and earn your staff without having a very good doll.

And, all the buffs for the staff make the doll more effective, efficient, and faster.

So, they are more like two halves of the same coin....... if you want to wax all philosophical like.

Maybe I'm weird, but I'm almost certain my doll was lvl 12 when I got staff... the same lvl it was around notoriety 15 when I began to think maybe I should work on the other weapons as well.

But on the topic, in my opinion, doll is better. I say for a couple significant reasons. That is,
a) You can use it to heal other pirates (very nifty, it'll do you good and your friends will appreciate it )
b) You have the "chicken with its head cut off" method as I like to call it, meaning you can run around and attack someone while they can't (often) attack you
c) With my skill point distribution, my doll's attacks are equally as powerful as my staff's
d) LIFE DRAIN- if any of you guys needed proof there is a God...
e) No charge up time. With all the staff passives maxed, the charge up time isn't too bad, but still, with doll you can generally throw one attack right after the other.
f) Doll takes a LOT less voodoo. If staff is used for a period of time, you may find yourself out of voodoo. This is rarely the case with doll.

WOW. This turned out to be a lot more than "a couple" reasons. lol. Well, that's just my two cents, and don't get me wrong, staff is a great weapon as well.

Wait, one more reason.
g) Doll actually can be useful even after it is mastered. (healing)

Ok, I'm done for real this time.

[Deadpool]

This is kinda a hard one here...

With the doll you can heal and be healed, (heal, cure, life drain). You might want to think about bringing tonics when using staff. As Jason pointed out above it does use a lot less voodo than staff. The doll is also a "portable weapon", meaning you can move and attack at the same time.

They say the best defence is a good offence, and the staff is the best example. It can be used on large groups of enemies. So why heal your friends when you can burn your enemies to a crisp with the staff? Most of the staffs spells do alot of damage to alot of enemies. The only drawback is you can't move and once again you run out of voodoo.

If you ask me which is best I would say staff... if you ask me which I can actually use I would say doll...

[DryWater]

I'm partial to the staff myself, but i'd call the doll "a jack/jill of all trades". I suppose that makes it more useful, especially to lower 30's levels.

--------- off topic ---------

There IS a way to run with a charged staff... but that's a glitch (if Edward Edgemenace wants to know how, i'll tell him and ONLY him. I don't want this one spreading like wildfire!) and this is not the post for that.

------- back on topic -------

[Timothy Willis]

I prefer the doll... reasons? ill tell you:

1. It doesnt hurt you

2. you can heal people

3. you can suck life out of low lvl enemies and get like +300

4. it can get you +40 voodoo if you max out... focus is it?

5. you can use grave shackles to keep someone in place... good in pvp

[Raikel]

Originally Posted by Timothy Willis

I prefer the doll... reasons? ill tell you:

1. It doesnt hurt you

2. you can heal people

3. you can suck life out of low lvl enemies and get like +300

4. it can get you +40 voodoo if you max out... focus is it?

5. you can use grave shackles to keep someone in place... good in pvp

Mistake #1, dolls are a way to get some people really angry in PvP, although, outside of PvP, I don't mind them all that much.

[akamystic]

This is another "it all depends" situation. I'm not going to board a high level flag ship and pull out the doll unless I plan on doing the chicken run. It's Flame or Wither all the way for that scenario. However, after getting pummeled and losing health you bet I'm switching to doll to chain n drain and probably start the chicken run anyway. This is typically when I'm alone or the crew have all been wiped out with 30+ lvl soldiers on board.

I'd have to say I use both the staff and doll equally. You cannot heal with the staff, but you can't do major devastation in a short time frame with the doll. Sure you can attune up to 5 enemies....but by the time you do that you've already taken a beating.

Indisputable (only covering what I use most):

Staff

-Soul Flay works decent when you are low on voodoo
-Pestilence not too shabby (does not use much voodoo)
-Wither rocks
-Flame kicks major booty
-Desolation...lets not go there in this thread as I have mixed feelings

Doll

-Poke not much damage but does not use much voodoo and recharges quickly
-Swarm does nice damage
-Heal is very useful
-Chains come in handy when running away or needing to distance yourself
-Life drain rocks (literally takes enemies health and transfers to your health)

[yahtzi3611]

listen,for those who think vodoo is not pirate like look at the name Pirates of the CARRIBEAN online down in the caribbean people believe in vodoo and spells and there are pirates down there too! Staff is best though you can decrease voodoo used and the hexes are definatly stronger than the vodoo doll but I mastered my doll anyway.

and desolation only hurts you witch is only a finisher you only say that as an excuse to say it is better than the staff.

[POTCO fan]

Originally Posted by bpg2012

Staff is not the most powerfull weapon i have flaming skull maxed and spirit mastery maxed too and i have siege and barrage maxed my flaming skull does about 1400-1600 how ever my siege does about 1500-2000 so yea staff isnt the most powerfull weapon

ever thought of 5 poinst in desolation? that would be stronger considering at 1 point it does about 1300 lol but it takes almost 70% of your life
so iI dont think 5 points in seige charge can beat 5 points in desolation.
but I think the staff is he most destructive weapon becasue if you see a huge mob of angry veterans runing at you. YOu want to just kill them all right?well just pull out staff and flaming skull them. And since the update they had on daggers doll is now much weaker(asp and throw dirt shater all your attunements which can get irritating in pvp)
so i think staff is the best.

[Dr. Zeppers]

The nature of the question is not clear...
Best based on what? Passive skills it offers? Or usefulness? How destructive it is?
How 'glitzy' a pirate thinks they are using it?
Do you PvP?
Do you quest?

"Best" cannot be determined as it is based on the individual pirates likes, dislikes, uses/needs, play style.

Ive said it before i'll say it again.

Most destructive: Staff (also best for being an annoying show off)

Most useful: Doll