Names are non-unique??

[TopRamen]

I got an awesome name for my secondary character approved the first day, because I KNEW it would be taken (Dread Pirate Roberts) now I finally got on that character and I found someone else with the same name! That's not cool... Either someone has the same name as me, or I have some weird bug where I see my name over someone else... Which is it?

Well, at least his character looks old, while mine looks like Wesley (if you don't understand, don't ask) so I can pretend that he's the old DPR and I'm the new...