Can you rate these pictures?

[MacIronhawk]

I've been trying to get some good/great pictures of POTCO because I thinking taking good/great pictures is challenging but fun and want to hear peoples opinions.

I have another thread way back in the forums here.

But can you rate these two pictures here?
I wanted to know how good they are.

I want to know because I think taking pictures is fun and want to get good at it.

[Dr. Zeppers]

Good Screens

The first one was rather unique, nice catch!

The second one, a nice screen, nothing "note worthy", but that can be hard to catch!

[Christopher Pugscream]

The first ones cool

Second one not so much.

[MacIronhawk]

Thanks for your opinions!
Yeah I didn't think the second one would be good.
The first one took about 3 tries so thank you.

[lostinthelab]

The first one is very cool! Good job.

The second one, while nothing unique like the first, is good. I might have zoomed in a bit though because there's nothing interesting in the edges of the capture; though, that can be nearly impossible to do on the fly while also doing battle.

Keep at it.

[Andrew]

i would give them both about the same rate. On a scale of 1-10 with 10 being the greatest, i would give them about a 6 =)

[Captain Del]

The first one it looks like you made the stump really angry because you burnt off all of its leafs.

The second one looks like the stump is trying to read something on the ground but it cant because it left its glasses at home, so it has to bend down and focus real good.

But on a serious note i feel you did a great job on the first one with the view of the camera, and same with the second one one, yet they arent great. I feel that one a scale of 1 to 5, your screenshots average would be about a 3 1/2.

[Swash]

First one is a 10.
Second one is an 8.