Full Review of POTC: On Stranger Tides

[Captain Sharktooth]

I am a huge POTC fan, but this wasn't the best movie. Sure, it had new settings and ideas added in that made it unique; that's what the good thing about it was. But it lacked some piratey 'moments' that were in the other movies. (If you haven't seen the movie, you may not wanna read this.) A lot of the movie was mostly traveling, and since there were no ship battles, that made it less 'piratey.' Also, when Blackbeard is first mentioned, he is "the pirate that all pirates fear." And he wasn't as fearful and intimidating as you would think, although the character was played very well. And why was the Catholic man an important character? Sure, he was trying to help save their souls, but I thought that wasn't necessary for the movie, and didn't give me the pirate feel.

But, this movie was still really good.

[Blaze Skullshield]

Originally Posted by Captain Sharktooth

I am a huge POTC fan, but this wasn't the best movie. Sure, it had new settings and ideas added in that made it unique; that's what the good thing about it was. But it lacked some piratey 'moments' that were in the other movies. (If you haven't seen the movie, you may not wanna read this.) A lot of the movie was mostly traveling, and since there were no ship battles, that made it less 'piratey.' Also, when Blackbeard is first mentioned, he is "the pirate that all pirates fear." And he wasn't as fearful and intimidating as you would think, although the character was played very well. And why was the Catholic man an important character? Sure, he was trying to help save their souls, but I thought that wasn't necessary for the movie, and didn't give me the pirate feel.

But, this movie was still really good.

To be releastic, it was rare for pirates to go into battle. As those voyages you see take somewhere around 10 days. And pirates didnt go into battle unless they needed or wanted to.

[Captain Sharktooth]

Originally Posted by Blaze Skullshield

To be releastic, it was rare for pirates to go into battle. As those voyages you see take somewhere around 10 days. And pirates didnt go into battle unless they needed or wanted to.

But compared to the other movies, there was way less action, and I was comparing this one to the other movies anyways.