Guild Attacked!

[Captain Del]

IMO, making every member an officer is not the best idea in the world. If everybody is an Officer, when the GM is not on, these people can cause as much trouble as they want, without getting reprimanded. Not mention, Officership should be more of a reward than a scheme to get a guild more members.

PIC has always used a very, very, very simple process when choosing Officers. We watch the member develop in our guild over time - see if they are friendly, well-liked amongst the guild, trustworthy, and all of that. Coupled with experience, it takes the average member 6 months to over a year to get promoted. This usually ensures the person you promote knows what they're doing.