Which Pirate Should I Level?

[James]

I have my maina ccount with nearly every quest done and all weapons mastered but 10 grenade level, 5 cannon levels, and a bunch of high rep quests were done after I hit 40.

Then I have my alt which also has all weapons master but hit 40 only a week ago and has lost no rep in the gap between then and the cap being raised.

Which is better to level first if I'm aiming for 50? Will the rep on my main eventually count or will this account never make it to 50?