One of my pirates won't load

[ohhmyylantaa]

I had unlimited access and I had made 3 pirates, one of which made it to level 33. I stopped playing, so I stopped paying and went down to basic access. I didn't want to delete my account in case I picked it up again, and I did.

Well I couldn't open that one pirate with basic access and I figured it was just because my account couldn't handle a pirate made with unlimited (even though I was playing a pirate previously made on unlimited. The difference was that this new pirate hadn't completed any quests.)

So when I upgraded to unlimited this morning, I hoped that I'd be able to play my lvl 33 pirate again. No such luck. It starts to load the Port Royal screen for a while, then the infamous box pops up saying that spiel about losing the internet connection. But I can still play my other pirates.

Anyone know why this happens? I even tried a quiet server, but no luck.