I recommend going to
live chat and they'll be able to get it back for you.
Available 10:00 AM to 7:00 PM - Pacific Time - Monday thru Friday
and 6:00 AM to 7:00 PM - Pacific Time - Saturday and Sunday
Yes there is a way to get it back!
DOn't worry. Toontown has gotten many of peoples deleted toons back and pirates is the same way. They'll keep a deleted pirate in the database and within 8-12 months they'll get rid of it for good.
Live chat should tell you what to do and then manage to get it back. But if you create a pirate in the spot where your pirate was then it is impossible to get it back so make sure you keep taht spot open.
(the spot whee you deleted the pirate)