Mmm I don't understand how you can mess up?? I'm lvl 35, my dagger is lvl 10, nade's are 1...I'm THANKFUL that I still have weapons that give me 100+rep each kill...all my other weapons give me like 20pts max now, if I'm lucky =( On, average, I get like 4pts each kill using my lvl 19 & higher weapons, it's so sad. I mean esp, when as high lvl as I am, almost everything is green lvled to me (or worse, grey!), but once I switch to my lower weapons, they are red-leveled to me, so 100+rep each kill is what I get. It's all about knowing how to lvl correctly to be able to get 100+rep each kill. You're probably using ur most powerful form of attack, so they die too fast. You get tons of rep depending on the # of times u hit it...
Edit: Definitely take a look at this:
http://www.piratesonlineforums.com/f...ead.php?t=6926 since u seem to be having trouble with getting a lot of rep for each kill. And this one too:
http://www.freewebs.com/longshotxx/potco/potco.htm look under "Max Rep"