Depends to me on just how mild/low level this other pirate is.
If hes strong enough to allow me to heal him, and have a chance at killing the Seabeard, then i'd go B. Heal the pirate, and kill the seabeard (presuming im helping him kill the seabeard at this point).
If hes weak, running around so I cant tag him to heal him, and not going to make it anyways... I just settle for D. (at least after the Seabeard stopped running around..)
As for E, wheres your sense of adventure!!!
Never F, id rather just watch him run...
Zeppers Lvl 38
http://pirates.teamofx.us