I said it depends. Mostly just because there might be certain things that would/wouldn't be needed in it. This kinda reminds me of my island from the May contest (look at my post on the design and island thread). I think that would be a cool type of PvP island. I'm sure there were a few others who posted a PvP island,... so if they mixed the best parts of each island together, we could have a fairly useful island!
