Aye, I partly agree with the Skull of Fire.
In all seriousness, you should only promote people you trust to officer. It's destroyed many a guild by having an untrustworthy member as officer. Veterans, that's different. Do what ya want with them. For number 2, it is not wrong to delete members for not coming on. After a few months, that's too much. Delete 'em. And as Davy said, could you reword number three a little better? The subforum policy as at the top, stickied.