Sergeant. Grrrr
 

OK, so I'm in the midst of doing the Black Pearl quest and I needed to get a sergeant from the Fort on Port Royal. Now, it sounds easy enough. But I've killed about 10 sergeants there, and it STILL isn't counting towards the quest. What gives?

Just keep killin'. Eventually you'll get the right one.

Look closely at the description, maybe your doing something wrong.

Well I finally got'em. Even though it said to kill a sergeant at Fort Charles, oddly enough my quest worked when I killed one on a boarded ship. I'm not sure if they do it at this form or not, but if they do, mods please lock this thread.

Always double check the journal, but sometimes it takes 20-30 to get that one you need.