Capturing Captain Archer?
 

Any suggestions for which ship to sink in order to capture Captain Arthur? I've tried several Navy Panthers and one Centurion with no luck. Any help would be greatly appreaciated.

I just did a search of old posts and found that I had trouble with capturing him too way back in Oct :p. I found him on a navy flag ship. Apparently in reading the post, I had to board many ships to capture him. But this was back in Oct, idk if things have changed since then :)

Good luck!

Anyone have more hints on this one? I'm doing it now and not having much luck. Is it pretty much just a matter of sinking enough frigates to finally find him?

Thats pretty much it, yeah.