Weapon Unlock - Rudyards Teeth
 

I just recently finished recruiting all of the members of Jack's Crew. A new weapon unlock appeared. It says it need to kill a skeleton nearby to recover a golden tooth lost by some pirate. I have been killing skeletons left and right, and still no tooth. So if anyone knows where or at least on what island they accomplished this task please share. Thanks alot, hearty plundering!! YOHO

Isn't it a treasure unlock? Rudyards Teeth is a treasure collection.

Thats what i meant
 

Sorry mates, i was thinkin of somthin different, but if ye do know where the skeleton is, thanks!

IDK if you're still stuck on this or not, but I just finished that today and finally got it on Padres Del Fuego. Still took lots of skeletons there too before I got it.

I swear they're making recovery tasks harder now, I never remember having this much trouble in beta.

If you kill a skeleton and it shows to the left side of your screen a message looking like this: "Searching for Golden Tooth...none found" that means you are killing the right skeletons and you just need to keep at it, till you get it.

Some users have experienced really looooong delays in getting their drops from certain mobs, while others have gotten them quicker. I believe it's just random on how quickly you get it.

I saw this quest, and got the first tooth, then ... nothing. Do I eventually get another part in my log, or is that it?

I currently just got all the teeth, but the first gold one for Jack is in a random skeleton. I killed about 50+ before I found it.